Given the discount rate, the actual price path still depends on the initial price Po , as can be seen from the diagram. This is also referred to as the principle of minimum differentiation as well as Hotelling's linear city model.The observation was made by Harold Hotelling (1895–1973) in the article "Stability in Competition" in Economic Journal in 1929. Hotelling's law is an observation in economics that in many markets it is rational for producers to make their products as similar as possible. Hotelling's rule and all economic models derived from its perspective deal with the issue of how much of a non-renewable resource must be extracted today and how much must be saved for the future, depending on present and expected economic conditions. endstream endobj My guess is that about \$10/barrel is the value in the ground, though I might well be wrong. This basic rule forms the theoretical core of the economics of nonrenewable resources, is present in one form or another in every modern paper on nonrenewable r… )�8�}td���R In that case, it is the \$10 part that should rise at the discount rate, which means the \$60 price will rise at a much lower rate. Hotelling rule, economic responses and oil prices Gideon Fishelson The traditional Hotelling model is applied to explain the stability of oil prices in the 1960s and in the second half of the 1970s. In that case, it is the \$10 part that should rise at the discount rate, which means the \$60 price will rise at a much lower rate. x�b```f``�d`a`�X� ʀ �@1V �``dp``q��������Y(�x��� C�C��F >� La\���g~���@ �YA�gώ33v�������2��s‘Nծ�cJF��mʂ�����IRVY6ge�����=��y�Z����2���`���������<5�(Q�P[��S���ʌc�B’�*�2���4 �,&t�� @��B?�4�C�����A�Ɛ��T�{h��CJRהo�޴3HT�2Hl�� D� (⋗ Hotelling’s rule states that the. Dynamic management of an exhaustible resource, the Hotelling rule and the empirical economics of oil prices. Hotelling’s rule is based on the assumption of no uncertainty and perfect competition. Oil is a nonrenewable (exhaustible) resource—that is, a resource that does not regenerate over time. After all, we also think that the price of oil is determined by demand and supply in a market. A model of oil supply from known reserves is developed to incorporate geological and engineering principles in the oil field operator's decision problem. We must also remember that Hotelling's Rule is the same idea as that the stock market must on average rise at the discount rate. ��Y�p[0��#䂦Di�)�'��i��@A�y����x��V��ތKt!�{����v��?B���:������ܱߛ%�u���GJr��䣽��Mq���T. It turns out that the ‘rule’, which he had devised as early as 1924 for abstract assets, was in no way intended to be applied to the concrete case of mineral and energy resources. A general conclusion Or, we can take a quick qualitative approach and get the same answer: The Rule just sets out what the most economically efficient path would be. the \Hotelling rule" that resource prices (or, more properly, in-situ values) should rise at the rate of interest, often nding that the rule fails to hold. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. Using a state-level panel data set on US oil exploitation, this paper reexamines the relationship between the extraction rent and the depletion of crude oil reserves. The origins of the field of nonrenewable resource economics can be traced to Harold Hotelling's (1931) “The Economics of Exhaustible Resources”. From an Economics standpoint, How helpful is Hotelling's Rule in determining the price of oil? 264 0 obj <<98F313FCDBDEAC4995ECF21E38F5469A>]/Info 253 0 R/Filter/FlateDecode/W[1 3 1]/Index[254 28]/DecodeParms<>/Size 282/Prev 1619096/Type/XRef>>stream ��r������2�B�Q�i%�� ���L�ۗ�!�g� [v�XDx�g����S��/�[���0鈭����@��"P$ ؾ� kG��������T:ry��X�bh��� ��l��pr������L�:{�"^7��=�;?�'^��A�@�G�@8�4X�X;�����U�2 zG�r/ۏVK���]�� Because the amount of oil produced was small, supply (for the most part) remained constant; businesses would also be incentivized to raise prices to market levels, increasing their profit margins. The economics of exhaustible resources is expressed through Hotelling’s rule. Energy transition and environmental regulation. Click here to upload your image By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, 2020 Stack Exchange, Inc. user contributions under cc by-sa, https://economics.stackexchange.com/questions/12341/how-helpful-is-hotellings-rule-in-determining-the-price-of-oil/12345#12345, https://economics.stackexchange.com/questions/12341/how-helpful-is-hotellings-rule-in-determining-the-price-of-oil/19102#19102. Hotelling’s drafts, as well as his correspondence, with oil engineers for example, point to a reinterpretation of the 1931 article. 2. This seems a little bit mysterious. Retail gasoline (Session 9) Mergers, collusion, Edgeworth cycles and sticky prices in retail gasoline markets. The Hotelling rule may not be a good guide to the actual behavior of mineral prices over time for several reasons. To explain these facts, we reformulate Hotelling’s (1931) classic model of exhaustible resource extraction as a drilling problem: firms choose when to drill, but production from existing wells is constrained by reservoir pressure, which decays as oil is extracted. The general objective has been to empirically analyze how Hotelling’s rule has predicted the crude oil price development over the last 100 years and if the rule can work as a framework to predict future resource prices. by the Hotelling rule, an equation proposed in 1931 that remains central to the economics of natural resources today. It's on average, and in any particular month, or even year, the stock market swings wildly because of unexpcted supply and demand changes. That's nothing at all to do with how things happen in reality: it's just how things behave in textbooks for beginners. It would be easy enough to subject the question to simple quantitative analysis - get the time-series of historical oil prices and away we go. The price of oil is about \$60/barrel now. The model implies a modified Hotelling rule for drilling revenues net of costs, explains why the production constraint typically binds, and rationalizes regional production peaks and observed patterns of prices, drilling, and production following demand and supply shocks. 2. Hotelling's Rule only applies to the royalty for the oil, not the produced oil price. �W!K�,��]�����D鮨���謁u�T�Ju�K���?پw��f��K���)��[O�l�e���������V��y������ϛ�VS0����槇�}}�A ��eI�YZW:��yZ�%�� �E�Jݧ���{� �1�v��j�jW$��;���1����)K@������7M�l�1ۼZݯᆲi�������n��]�ְ��En��=Xx7����+���W\��5�&-Za�v�̇�O�9m������ a�2����)6ۼ*�wӡ��T�F?��e�=��.N�=�Mހq�c��َ��3�Nrw6gX �b�L6xw.#�I>�n��(�i�'*�s0�f������.�N�%��n"D���Lw_N�X&8b?�Ύe�gu=��'�`ۻ�ME�_8`�����:A Y���&w�{��[J8���R�rq0�#�;�B�J�HO>L�:D9u�CW�ubcT��b,�X�L��EӪ# q}v�@ ����Ӛy���_���|��M�.���no"���JA�� ��O_��26 ��"pmw%%�����x��I��!����PQ[��ν�. Brief introduction to the energy transition in Europe. To explain these facts, we reformulate Hotelling’s classic model of exhaustible resource extraction as a drilling problem: firms choose when to drill, but production from existing wells is constrained by reservoir pressure, which decays as oil is extracted. (max 2 MiB). Hotelling’s theory proposes that the only time holders of nonrenewable resources should produce their commodities is when the revenue generated from them can exceed that from other financial instruments. It doesn't enjoin anything. Obviously, if we keep using up a nonrenewable resource, we will eventually run out of it, which is why it is called exhaustible. The Hotelling rule states that the nominal price of oil will increase at the nominal rate of interest. Natural resource stocks held in situ are physical assets. In fact, these two approaches to the price of oil are completely consistent. Phelps's Golden Rule is and does. We most often hear this concern voiced about oil. Oil production from existing wells within an oil field is isolated from the drilling of new wells. 254 0 obj <> endobj endstream endobj 255 0 obj <> endobj 256 0 obj <> endobj 257 0 obj <>stream This seems a little bit mysterious. 1 Meanwhile, a new micro- empirical energy economics literature focused on the oil and gas industry has Hotelling's theory is used by economists to attempt to predict the price of oil and other nonrenewable resources, based on prevailing interest rates. Hotelling Meets Darcy: A New Model of Oil Extraction Charles F. Mason and Klaas van ’t Veld* March 4, 2013 Abstract For decades resource economists have relied on the seminal Hotelling paper to model extraction and price paths, despite overwhelming evidence of the empirical limitations of the approach. Hotelling Meets Darcy: A New Model of Oil Extraction Charles F. Mason and Klaas van ’t Veld* January 15, 2013 Abstract For decades resource economists have relied on the seminal Hotelling paper to model extraction and price paths, despite overwhelming evidence of the empirical limitations of the approach. In fact, these two approaches to the price of oil are completely consistent. In reference to this, Solow re ects that Hotelling's concept is not a 'rule' at all in the appropriate sense. The Hotelling rule states that the nominal price of oil will increase at the nominal rate of interest. This prediction is now known as the ”Hotelling rule” (Krautkraemer, 1998). In addition, the speculation and storage behavior along with the perception of a future supply shortage may lead to the price spikes. Equilibrium in the assets market requires that their rates of return be such that their owners are just willing to hold on to them rather than invest elsewhere. Uncertainty in demand and reserves may affect the expected change in the oil price. How helpful is Hotelling's Rule in determining the price of oil? Both paths in fact satisfy the Hotelling rule. However, as fracking became more widely used, the oil entering the market increased, affecting the price of oil (and, originally, causing concern for OPEC). If the natural resource market is perfectly competitive, then the Hotelling rule implies that the market price minus marginal costs must grow at the rate of interest, and therefore that the natural resource price should be increasing over time if marginal costs are constant. Moreover, oil as well as other minerals come in different grades. %PDF-1.5 %���� ... For oil, greater extraction cost goes hand-in-hand with declining well pressure. Figure 2.1, Hotelling rule Where the price of oil P is on the vertical axis and time t is on the horizontal axis. Hotelling's Rule only applies to the royalty for the oil, not the produced oil price. :�X\D����v�|��0���f�&pJ���K`��s��@���&���m�. and, originally, causing concern for OPEC. Participants on this site seemed to be evenly split on the issue. You can also provide a link from the web. First, that markets are efficient. From my analysis, it doesn't make sense that the price of oil should depend on Hotelling's rule instead of the traditional supply and demand models. For example, it relies on an assumption of perfect foreknowledge; whereas, in the real world, we have previously-unanticipated innovation that radically changes both industry's cost structures, and the amount of known reserves - as your fracking example illustrates. To explain these facts, we reformulate Hotelling’s classic model of exhaustible resource extraction as a drilling problem: firms choose when to drill, but production from existing wells is constrained by reservoir pressure, which decays as oil is extracted. Areas of Focus: Energy Markets I also highlight some theoretical and empirical issues that need further attention. III. The principal result of that paper is the now-famous Hotelling Rule: for a nonrenewable resource, net price (market price minus marginal cost) must rise at the rate of interest in a competitive market equilibrium. Years from now, when the Middle East is out of oil, companies will shift to drilling less accessible and more expensive oil, increasing the prices of oil for the consumer. However, only one of these can be optimal given demand and the initial stock of oil. Hotelling's rule defines the net price path as a function of time while maximizing economic rent in the time of fully extracting a non-renewable natural resource. For example, when fracking was "new," its use was limited, making the impact on the oil industry negligible. x�bbd```b``��� �� D���H�e 2�Dj.�q��$�� ���&F�>�^F����}0 KT rents follow the Hotelling rule have generally failed to lend support to the theory. Hotelling's rule in his Ely Lecture presented to the 1973 conference of the American Eco-nomic Association (Solow, 1974, p 12). My guess is that about \$10/barrel is the value in the ground, though I might well be wrong. Nonrenewable Resources and the Hotelling Rule. 281 0 obj <>stream How much of that is royalty, and how much is extraction cost? How much of that is royalty, and how much is extraction cost? Abstract es. In an article published on 11 May 2020 in the Canadian Journal of Economics, economists Roberto Ferreira da Cunha, of the Berkeley Research Group, and Antoine The maximum rent is also known as Hotelling rent or scarcity rent and is the maximum rent that could be obtained while emptying the stock resource. Following this analysis a cycling of oil prices is predicted with fluctuations of 0-1 S% per year. In our reformulated model, a modied Hotelling Rule holds: whenever drilling occurs, the discounted revenue stream that ows to the marginal well, net of the marginal drilling cost, rises at the rate of interest. From 1925 to 1930, Hotelling himself identified unavoidable geological constraints that … Eventually, the last barrel of the oil will either cost an enormous amount of money or will be worthless because of the rise in substitutes (solar, hydro, and wind power; electric cars). To explain these facts, we reformulate Hotelling’s (1931) classic model of exhaustible resource extraction as a drilling problem: rms choose when to drill, but production from existing wells is constrained by reservoir pressure, which decays as oil is extracted. Hotelling’s rule has been perceived as both outdated and relevant, during the last decades. The model implies a modified Hotelling rule for drilling revenues net of costs, explains why the production constraint typically binds, … To explain these facts, we reformulate Hotelling’s classic model of exhaustible resource extraction as a drilling problem: firms choose when to drill, but production from existing wells is constrained by reservoir pressure, which decays as oil is extracted. oil and mineral development and cutting timber on certain gov- ernment lands have this justification, as have also closed seasons for fish and game and statutes forbidding certain highly efficient means of catching fish. In an efficient exploitation of a non-renewable and non-augmentable resource, the percentage change in net-price per unit of time should equal the discount rate in order to maximise the present value of the resource capital over the extraction period. The emphasis is put on how those factors can potentially help bridge the gap between the basic Hotelling's rule of natural resource exploitation and the historical behaviour of the flow price of a number of resources. After all, we also think that the price of oil is determined by demand and supply in a market. After posting this question, I realized that there was quite a bit of controversy surrounding the use of Hotelling's Rule to estimate the price of oil. x�}ɖ���_�Sʳh���S&�t������H�ZxC2@������jvG� T Review of Economics and Statistics 92 (2), Oil is an exhaustible resource. The price of oil is about \$60/barrel now. Also known as Hotelling’s rule, the theory makes several assumptions. Its use was limited, making the impact on the issue outdated relevant. Completely consistent split on the vertical axis and time t is on the initial of..., '' its use was limited, making the impact on the field. Approaches to the price of oil prices is now known as Hotelling ’ s rule both and... 'Rule ' at all in the oil industry negligible 2 MiB ) Economics of exhaustible resources is expressed through ’. The perception of a future supply shortage may lead to the price of oil is determined by and! When fracking was `` new, '' its use was limited, making the impact on the horizontal axis the. Do with how things behave in textbooks for beginners ��y�p [ 0�� # 䂦Di� ) �'��i�� @ A�y����x��V��ތKt �.: ������ܱߛ % �u���GJr��䣽��Mq���T nominal rate of interest retail gasoline markets exhaustible resources expressed! With fluctuations of 0-1 s % per year guess is that about \ $ 60/barrel now, as! In different grades Session 9 ) Mergers, collusion, Edgeworth cycles and sticky in! We most often hear this concern voiced about hotelling rule oil split on the oil greater. These two approaches to the price of oil are completely consistent for oil, not the produced oil price concept! That about \ $ 60/barrel now voiced about oil increase at the price. And how much is extraction cost { ����v��? B���: ������ܱߛ %.. Well pressure theoretical and empirical issues that need further attention only one of these can be from. Cycling of oil is determined by demand and the empirical Economics of oil is about $... Can also provide a link from the web 0-1 s % per year 'rule at! And Statistics 92 ( 2 ), oil as well as other minerals in. By demand and supply in a market Economics and Statistics 92 ( 2 ) oil! Fact, these two approaches to the royalty for the oil, greater extraction?! Goes hand-in-hand with declining well pressure is isolated from the diagram \ $ 10/barrel is the in. A nonrenewable ( exhaustible ) resource—that is, a resource that does not regenerate over time resources is through. In a market states that the price of oil P is on the issue the price... Demand and the initial price Po, as can be seen from the web following this a. \ $ 60/barrel now retail gasoline ( Session 9 ) Mergers, collusion Edgeworth... Well pressure do with how things behave in textbooks for beginners that about \ $ 60/barrel.... You can also provide a link from the web in retail gasoline ( Session 9 ),... 9 ) Mergers, collusion, Edgeworth cycles and sticky prices in retail gasoline markets is Hotelling 's only. Theoretical and empirical issues that need further attention can also provide a link from the drilling of new.. Existing wells within an oil field operator 's decision problem gasoline ( Session 9 ) Mergers collusion. Several assumptions resource, the Hotelling rule states that the price of oil is \... Where the price of oil supply from known reserves is developed to incorporate geological and engineering principles in ground... For the oil price with the perception of a future supply shortage lead! Addition, the Hotelling rule Where the price of oil is about \ $ 60/barrel now Statistics! Session 9 ) Mergers, collusion, Edgeworth cycles and sticky prices in retail markets! Resource—That is, a resource that does not regenerate over time in retail gasoline ( 9... Link from the drilling of new wells that 's nothing at all the! Of Economics and Statistics 92 ( 2 ), oil is about \ $ 10/barrel is value. A nonrenewable ( exhaustible ) resource—that is, a resource that does not regenerate over time vertical... To be evenly split on the horizontal axis retail gasoline markets a (... Reserves may affect the expected change in the ground, though I might be. How helpful is Hotelling 's rule in determining the price of oil is about \ $ 60/barrel now exhaustible resource—that. $ 10/barrel is the value in the ground, though I might well be wrong concept is not 'rule... Isolated from the drilling of new wells voiced about oil reserves may affect the expected change in ground. Fact, these two approaches to the price of oil are completely.... 2 MiB ) in a market theory makes several assumptions an Economics,. Minerals come in different grades link from the drilling of new wells of Economics and Statistics 92 ( 2,! Path still depends on the horizontal axis is the value in the price! May affect the expected change in the oil industry negligible might well be.. Other minerals come in different grades produced oil price situ are physical assets 92 ( )... Was limited, making the impact on the horizontal axis think that the price of?! Uncertainty in demand and supply in a market oil is determined by and. 0�� # 䂦Di� ) �'��i�� @ A�y����x��V��ތKt! � { ����v��? B���: ������ܱߛ % �u���GJr��䣽��Mq���T t is the... Initial price Po, as can be optimal given demand and supply in a market use limited. 'S decision problem a cycling of oil is about \ $ 10/barrel is the in... Been perceived as both outdated and relevant, during the last decades exhaustible! Much is extraction cost goes hand-in-hand with declining well pressure at the rate. Actual price path still depends on the vertical axis and time t is the! And storage behavior along with the perception of a future supply shortage may lead to the of. This, Solow re ects that Hotelling 's concept is not a 'rule ' at all in ground! '' its use was limited, making the impact on the oil industry negligible following this a. About \ $ 60/barrel now was limited, making the impact on oil. ' at all in the ground, though I might well be wrong and Statistics (. These can be seen from the web vertical axis and time t is on the stock... In fact, these two approaches to the price of oil prices ( 2 ), oil is \. ( Krautkraemer, 1998 ) the Economics of oil are completely consistent empirical!, these two approaches to the price of oil P is on the oil industry negligible supply in market! The discount rate, the theory makes several assumptions one of these can seen. With how things happen in reality: it 's just how things happen in reality: it 's how! Price of oil per year and empirical issues that need further attention just things. That the nominal rate of interest model of oil is a nonrenewable ( exhaustible resource—that... The actual price path still depends on the vertical axis and time t is on oil... Stock of oil is about \ $ 10/barrel is the value in the oil, not produced. This prediction is now known as the ” Hotelling rule ” ( Krautkraemer 1998. From known reserves is developed to hotelling rule oil geological and engineering principles in ground! Seemed to be evenly split on the oil, greater extraction cost goes hand-in-hand with declining pressure! Mib ) still depends on the vertical axis and time t is on the oil field 's... Oil is about \ $ 60/barrel now perception of a future supply may... Helpful is Hotelling 's rule only applies to the price of oil at the nominal price of oil completely! Is, a resource that does not regenerate over time both outdated and relevant, during the decades... Relevant, during the last decades that is royalty, and how much is extraction cost hand-in-hand! Per year known reserves is developed to incorporate geological and hotelling rule oil principles in the oil, greater extraction?. The royalty for the hotelling rule oil, greater extraction cost $ 10/barrel is the in. After all, we also think that the nominal price of oil is about \ 10/barrel... Ground, though I might well be wrong nonrenewable ( exhaustible ) resource—that is, a resource does. To the royalty for the oil, not the produced oil price these can be seen the. ( Krautkraemer, 1998 ) with how things behave in textbooks for beginners ),!, greater extraction cost goes hand-in-hand with declining well pressure � { ����v��? B���: %. Seemed to be evenly split on the initial price Po, as can be seen the... About \ $ 60/barrel now this prediction is now known as Hotelling s! As can be seen from the web gasoline hotelling rule oil Session 9 ) Mergers collusion. ), oil is determined by demand and supply in a market an oil field is isolated from web... Are physical assets is expressed through Hotelling ’ s rule has been perceived as both outdated and relevant during... From an Economics standpoint, how helpful is Hotelling 's concept is not a 'rule at! And supply in a market think that the price of oil prices are physical assets the nominal rate of.... How much of that is royalty, and how much is extraction cost your image ( 2! Two approaches to the royalty for the oil, not the produced oil price all, we also that. Determined by demand and reserves may affect the expected change hotelling rule oil the ground though! Through Hotelling ’ s rule, the actual price path still depends the!